The archaeology of infancy and infanticide
Session Organiser: Eleanor Scott
(King Alfred's College, Winchester)
The idea of the session is to stimulate
and challenge the way in which we are thinking archaeologically about infants
(or indeed not thinking about them). Infancy is surrounded and defined
by social and historical constructions, but little significance has been
attached to the processes which determined how infants lived, died and
were perceived. This session therefore examines the ways in which patterns
of infant care were (and are) metaphors for complex social beliefs and
tensions. Further, in some contexts the infant is clearly transformed into
a powerful symbol. The session looks in particular at infant death, including
practices of infanticide and child sacrifice in different cultural contexts
and the ways in which different societies bury and commemorate their infant
dead. Critical questions such as whether or not preferential female infanticide
was routinely practised in prehistory and antiquity - and the potential
implications of this - will be raised and discussed, as will whether or
not infants are "missing" from cemeteries because of differential preservation.
The session speakers will also present new data, including an evaluation
of recent research on the DNA sexing of infant skeletal material in Israel
and the UK, as well as excavation of and research on recently excavated
capacocha sacrifices in Peru. In conclusion, it is mooted that the infant
and infancy are crucial components in the cultural maps of human societies,
and infants can no longer be regarded as merely small humans of culturally
inactive status. Infants may not be active agents but infancy has
active agency.
Eleanor Scott
(Department of Archaeology, King Alfred's
University College, Winchester SO22 4NR)
Introduction. Metaphors, tensions and routes
to posterity: the archaeology of infancy and infanticide
We all share the experience of having
been infants, yet it is the one stage of our lives of which we have no
memory. The collective memory of infancy is a construction, where fantasies
and ideals crash hard into lived realities and actualities. What many adults
regard as the simple routines of infant care are in fact complex negotiations
which result from and impact upon the anxieties and tensions surrounding
our biological and cultural periodicity. The infant is trained into routines
in such a way as to force the players into a sustained drama of control
and accession. The association of childbirth and infants with widespread
human symbolic concerns, such as the containment of excrement, urine and
blood, and the control of noise and movement, makes them embodiments of
powerful cultural processes with particular meanings in particular societies.
The manipulation of the infant, the infant dead, infant space and images
of the infant frequently acts as metaphor for adult relationships and tensions,
from the micro-scale of the family to the macro-scale of major political
systems. Infant ritual sacrifice, for example, reveals a relationship between
biological genetic imperatives and human attempts to lock into posterity
in other, cultural, ways.
Steve Bourget
(Department of Archaeology, King Alfred's
University College, Winchester SO22 4NR)
Too young to die and too old to care: children
and ancestors at Huaca de la Luna
During the 1995 and 1996 field seasons,
the remains of three children were discovered in a special plaza of the
Huaca de la Luna, one of the principal ceremonial centres of the Moche
culture on the Peruvian North Coast. They were found lying just underneath
a series of sacrificed men captured in battle and killed during spells
of torrential rains or Nino events. In this paper, it will be argued that
these children form an integral part of the sacrificial apparatus dedicated
to the world of the sea and more particularly to the cataclysmic Nino events.
In order to document further these exceptional rituals, the representations
of children and sacrifices portrayed in their ritual iconography will be
explored.
K Alexandra Lee
(University of Cambridge, Cambridge)
Infant sacrifice at Carthage and the social
ideal of the child
This paper discusses the role of child
sacrifice at the tophet of Carthage and its relationship to the construction
of the social ideal of the child. Also addressed is the crucial matter
of the demographic implications of infant and child sacrifice.
John Pearce
(Department of Archaeology, University
of Durham, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE)
Constructions of infancy - aspects of the mortuary
rituals for infants and children in late Iron Age and Roman Britain (and
neighbouring provinces)
A striking and well known aspect of
this period is the under-representation of the bodies of infants and children
in formal cemetery contexts. Their deposition, sometimes in large numbers,
on settlement sites, has been the subject of much recent study. The emphasis
of this paper lies instead on the mortuary treatment of those infants and
children which are buried in 'normal' cemeteries, in particular cremation
cemeteries of the period in question. It is now widely acknowledged that
mortuary rituals do not create a mirror image of a society but idealised
representations of it. The aim of this paper is therefore to explore the
creation of these representations through the detailed reconstruction and
contrast of the treatment of infants/ young children and adults from the
pyre to the grave. Beneath the superficial similarities of 'Romanised'
mortuary ritual, highly diverse treatments are visible which are not so
far accounted for by broad statements on the changing conception of the
child.
Simon Mays
(English Heritage, 23 Savile Row,
London W1X 1AB)
New directions in the scientific study of infant
skeletons from archaeological sites
A trawl of the archaeological literature
published in Britain shows that immature human skeletons, particularly
infants, are usually given short shrift in osteological studies. However,
the situation is changing. Recent innovations in archaeological science
have increased the information obtainable from skeletal remains of infants
and children, and there has been a growing realisation in general that
the archaeology of infancy and childhood has been a somewhat neglected
area. The purpose of this paper is to discuss some of the recent advances
in scientific methodologies for examining infant remains, and to discuss
the relevance of the data produced to matters of mainstream archaeological
and historical interest.
Marina Faerman
(Dept of Anatomy, The Hebrew University
of Jerusalem, POB 12272, Jerusalem, 1120, Israel)
Determining the sex of infanticide victims
from the Late Roman era through ancient DNA analysis
Infanticide has since time immemorial
been an accepted practice for disposing of unwanted infants. Archaeological
evidence for infanticide was obtained in Ashkelon, where skeletal remains
of some 100 neonates were discovered in a sewer, beneath a Roman bathhouse,
which might also have served as a brothel. Written sources indicate that
in ancient Roman society infanticide especially of females was commonly
practised, but that females were occasionally saved and reared as courtesans.
We performed DNA-based sex identification of the infant remains. Out of
43 left femurs tested 19 specimens provided results: 14 were found to be
males and 5 females. The high frequency of males suggests selective preservation
of females and that the infants may have been offspring of courtesans,
serving in the bathhouse, supporting its use as a brothel.